Should There Be Heroes In Product Management?

In product management, it's easy to find oneself donning the cape of a hero. But what if the true path to success and impact goes beyond the allure of being the team's go-to savior?

In this episode, Hannah Clark is joined by Clement Kao—Founder of Product Teacher—to delve into the intricacies of heroism in product management and explore strategies for empowering product teams more sustainably.

Interview Highlights

  • Clement’s Journey from Management Console to Product Teacher [00:54]
    • Clement's background is non-traditional, starting as a management consultant, then transitioning to UX researcher, data analyst, and finally becoming a product manager.
    • He noticed that many others faced similar struggles in product management, lacking resources and guidance.
    • As he progressed in his career, Clement realized he could make a bigger impact by helping other product managers succeed.
    • This led him to found Product Teacher, aiming to assist product managers in various stages of their careers, from beginners to senior professionals.
    • Product Teacher has supported over 7,000 product managers in areas such as entering the field, advancing their careers, and developing product strategies and processes.
  • Redefining Heroism in Product Management [02:44]
    • Clement clarifies that heroism in product management isn't inherently bad; it's about the frequency and context of its application.
    • Product managers are expected to take charge and resolve issues when necessary, but relying on heroism too often can lead to problems.
    • Over-reliance on heroism can lead to other team members neglecting their responsibilities, causing the organization to suffer.
    • When a product manager becomes the sole hero, it weakens other areas of the organization, making it dependent on one individual.
    • There should be a balance, with product managers stepping in only when truly necessary, not as a daily or weekly routine.
    • If heroism is a frequent requirement, it indicates deeper issues within the organization that need addressing.

Product managers should be ready to step up when needed. However, if this becomes a frequent occurrence, there may be underlying issues that require attention.

Clement Kao
  • Why Product Managers End Up Wearing Too Many Hats [04:54]
    • Clement explains that many product managers find themselves in positions of heroism due to changes in how work is structured over time.
    • Cross-matrixing of responsibilities has become common, with individuals supporting multiple initiatives or teams simultaneously.
    • Lack of clarity about who should handle specific tasks leads to defaulting to the product manager.
    • Startups and smaller teams often lack clear guidelines on task allocation, leading to product managers taking on various responsibilities.
    • Once a product manager successfully handles a task, it creates a self-reinforcing loop where they're expected to continue doing it.
    • Examples include product managers taking on analytics, market research, customer discussions, or sales conversations indefinitely.
    • The trend has intensified over the past decade, with product managers being overloaded due to their perceived competence in various areas.
  • Identifying and Addressing Organizational Weaknesses [06:58]
    • Clement suggests that frequent instances of product managers needing to be heroes can indicate organizational shortcomings.
    • Occasional heroics are expected, but recurring patterns suggest deeper issues.
    • Organizations that value retrospectives should use them to analyze problems and prevent recurrence.
    • If similar issues happen repeatedly, it's crucial to address the underlying causes to prevent product managers from regularly taking on tasks beyond their scope.
    • Regular retrospectives should help identify and rectify patterns of product managers being overloaded or taking on tasks they shouldn't be handling.
  • Effective Retrospectives: A Tool for Organizational Change [08:07]
    • Clement emphasizes the importance of blameless retrospectives in addressing systemic issues.
    • He advocates for focusing on the system, not individuals, during retrospectives.
    • Using an example from air traffic control, he illustrates how failures are rarely the fault of a single person but rather a result of systemic issues.
    • Retrospectives should aim to improve the system to prevent failures rather than placing blame.
    • The mindset during retrospectives should be collaborative, focusing on how to make the system better for everyone.
    • Continuous improvement should be the goal, ensuring that the burden doesn't fall solely on the product manager each time a problem arises.

One important aspect of running a retrospective is ensuring that it remains blameless, focusing on the system and not the people.

Clement Kao
  • Personal and Organizational Case Studies on Role Clarity [11:15]
    • Clement shares a personal story about a time when he took on too many product ops responsibilities, hindering team growth.
      • Initially, he felt it was his duty as a product manager to ensure the product's success, but he later realized he was undermining his teammates by not delegating tasks.
      • His manager intervened and helped him recognize the need to delegate responsibilities to other team members to ensure scalability and long-term success.
      • Key factors in successful remediation included leadership buy-in, reframing responsibilities as opportunities for ownership, and regular check-ins to ensure a smooth transition.
      • The experience taught Clement the importance of sharing responsibilities and empowering teammates to take ownership of their tasks.
    • Clement also shares a recent case study from a large organization where the product team transitioned from solution architecture to product management.
      • Initially, the team, comprised mostly of former solution architects, struggled to differentiate their roles, leading to overlap and confusion.
      • The product team inadvertently took on solution architecture tasks, hindering scalability and long-term success.
      • Through multiple touch points and discussions, the team realigned their roles, clarifying that product managers focus on core product development while solution architects handle customer-specific solutions.
      • The team's openness to feedback and willingness to redefine their relationship early on contributed to their success.
      • This proactive approach prevented long-term issues and ensured that each team member owned tasks relevant to their role, fostering scalability and efficiency.
  • Mindsets and Maturity: Navigating Organizational Growth [21:46]
    • Reflect on personal workload regularly to identify tasks not aligned with core product responsibilities. Acknowledge feelings of being overwhelmed or underwater, which may indicate misalignment in role expectations.
    • Inform your manager about tasks consuming time not related to core product responsibilities. Present data on time allocation and the reasons behind the workload imbalance. Managers benefit from understanding misalignments as it helps them meet team metrics effectively.
    • Collaborate with your manager to identify tasks better suited for other teams. Communicate why certain tasks should be transferred and how it contributes to organizational scalability. Initiate conversations with relevant teams to facilitate the transfer of responsibilities.
    • Ensure a smooth transition of tasks to the appropriate teams. Provide necessary context and support for the new teams taking over responsibilities. Regularly check in to ensure successful integration and address any issues that arise.
    • Achieve a cleaner focus on core product responsibilities, leading to more impactful outcomes. Gain additional time to engage deeply with customers, design, engineering, and business strategies. Experience a clearer mind and enhanced productivity by delegating non-core tasks effectively.
    • Allocate time specifically for strategizing and planning workload sustainability. Adopt a dual persona approach where one persona is dedicated to executing tasks and another to strategizing and planning. Recognize the importance of personal stakeholder needs in driving effective product management practices.

Meet Our Guest

Clement Kao is Founder of Product Teacher, a product management education company that accelerates product talent through corporate training workshops, on-demand video courses, and executive coaching. Before founding Product Teacher, Clement shipped 10+ multi-million dollar products as a group product manager at multiple companies, driving successful exits worth billions of dollars in aggregate. Clement’s writing has been featured on Amplitude, Mixpanel, Gainsight, and other leading publications.

photo of Clement Kao

One thing product managers often forget is that they themselves are critical stakeholders and cannot neglect this aspect while executing their roles.

Clement Kao

Resources from this episode:

You may also like